Skip to main content

JTFRA Guiding Principles

January 21, 2014 by Steven D. Brewer

The Joint Task Force for Resource Allocation at UMass created a draft set of guiding principles that included language about incentivizing. This is my reply:

I read the JTFRA draft guiding principles with interest and would like to offer one recommendation: reword to avoid creating incentives.

Creating incentives is always a mistake. There is extensive research that shows that rewards don't work -- See Alfie Kohn's "Punished by Rewards" and Daniel Pink's "Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us" for two recent examples.

Incentives try to shape behavior by encouraging people to aim for the reward rather than to do what they think is right. It's worth thinking about that. How much time do we want people to spend trying to get rewards rather than trying to do their job as well as they can?

Using rewards and incentives also encourages perverse behavior. It undermines honesty and candor because people try to manipulate the data and appearances to increase the likelihood of receiving the reward -- and to undermine people around them, with whom they are competing.

Finally, the statement "incentivize excellence" is meaningless. What does "incentivize excellence" even mean? Only do things we can do excellently? Just as "something worth doing is worth doing well", it is equally true that "something worth doing is worth doing badly". It's often better to do something badly than not to do it at all.

Ask. Create opportunities. Invest. Don't incentivize.



February 1, 2014 by Steven D. Brewer, 1 year 42 weeks ago
Comment: 1561

I was pleased to see at the most recent Faculty Senate meeting that they've fixed this. Thank you!


provis organizi ion sensukcese / should know better than to get exercised about esperantists. — 27 min 53 sec ago
M$ Word does it on Mac. If you hit delete, it takes the space, but if you type something, it replaces the word & leaves the space. — 2 hours 3 min ago
waited until it was clear that no students were attending class & then left work a little early to take his mom to run pre-holiday errands. — 3 hours 57 min ago
I would favorite this tweet, if still made that possible. — 4 hours 2 min ago
purchased enough chaotic matter for the keylocker bundle & enough left over to maybe get some beacons or something / temas pri . — 5 hours 28 min ago
Premium Drupal Themes by Adaptivethemes